By Ronn Torossian, Founder and Chairman of 5W. Updated November 21, 2026. Reviewed by the 5W editorial team.
Only 8 of 50 earnings-release headlines name revenue, and 18 name guidance, based on a 5WPR audit of 50 U.S. public companies for quarters ending July to September 2026. In 32 releases the first explanation of the quarter sits in an executive quote or a later section, so readers who stop at the bullets get numbers without reasons.
Table of contents
- What did the study measure?
- What do earnings-release headlines lead with?
- Where does guidance appear when it goes up or down?
- What happens to the opening when revenue falls?
- Does the explanation come before the executive quote?
- Do companies put GAAP or adjusted earnings first?
- Did one sector drive these patterns?
- What should an earnings-release opening look like?
- What are the limits of this study?
- Conclusion
- Frequently asked questions
Summary
- Headlines are thin. Revenue appears in 8 of 50 headline blocks (16%), GAAP earnings in 6 (12%), and guidance in 18 (36%).
- Raised guidance gets a direction word, lowered guidance gets "updates." Raised guidance reached the headline block in 13 of 18 releases (72%), 11 of them with a word such as raises or increases. Lowered or mixed guidance reached it in 3 of 8 (38%), and none used a direction word.
- Falling revenue is rarely in the opening. None of the 5 releases with falling revenue named the decline in the headline block, and only 1 stated it in the opening bullets.
- Reasons come late. Only 18 of 50 releases (36%) explain the quarter in the headline block or opening bullets. 26 (52%) wait for the executive quote and 6 (12%) wait for a later section.
- GAAP usually comes first. 4 of 50 releases led with a non-GAAP figure before the GAAP figure.
This is a benchmark of issuer messaging. It does not measure investor response or which structure performs best.
What did the study measure?
The study measured what 50 U.S. public companies put in the headline block, the opening text and the first executive quote of their third-quarter earnings releases.
The sample is 25 companies from the S&P 500 and 25 from the S&P MidCap 400. Each release covers a fiscal quarter that ended between July 1 and September 30, 2026, was published by November 20, 2026, and reports a year-over-year revenue comparison. 5WPR built the sample from public index lists, sorted each pool with a fixed hash rule, capped any sector at 6 companies, and froze the roster before reading a single release. Every release comes from the issuer's investor relations site or an SEC Form 8-K exhibit.
Two terms matter below. The headline block is the headline plus any subheads or top bullets above the dateline. The opening text is the dateline paragraph plus any highlight bullets before the first executive quote. For each release, 5WPR coded which of five items appeared in each place: revenue, GAAP earnings, adjusted earnings, guidance and an operating metric such as orders, same-store sales or production.
| Sample feature | Count |
|---|---|
| Releases audited | 50 |
| S&P 500 companies | 25 |
| S&P MidCap 400 companies | 25 |
| Releases with rising revenue | 45 (90%) |
| Releases with falling revenue | 5 (10%) |
| Releases with annual guidance | 43 (86%) |
| Sectors covered | 11, with no more than 6 companies in any one |
What do earnings-release headlines lead with?
Earnings-release headlines mostly name the company and the period, and little else: revenue appears in the headline block of 8 of 50 releases (16%).
Guidance is the item most often added to a headline. It appears in 18 headline blocks (36%), ahead of operating metrics (11, or 22%), adjusted earnings (9, or 18%), revenue (8, or 16%) and GAAP earnings (6, or 12%). The opening bullets and dateline fill the gap. GAAP earnings show up in the headline or opening text of 44 releases (88%), adjusted earnings in 41 (82%), and revenue in 29 (58%).
| Item | In headline block | In headline or opening text |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 8 of 50 (16%) | 29 of 50 (58%) |
| GAAP earnings | 6 of 50 (12%) | 44 of 50 (88%) |
| Adjusted earnings | 9 of 50 (18%) | 41 of 50 (82%) |
| Guidance | 18 of 50 (36%) | 28 of 50 (56%) |
| Operating metric | 11 of 50 (22%) | 32 of 50 (64%) |
So earnings per share is the figure readers meet first, and revenue is the figure they often meet second. The thinnest opening in the sample belongs to Guidewire, whose fiscal fourth-quarter release carries no financial figure before the first executive quote, a quote that opens with "AI is driving our momentum."
Where does guidance appear when it goes up or down?
Raised guidance moves into the headline block more often than lowered guidance, and it carries a direction word: 13 of 18 raises (72%) appear there, 11 of them with a word such as raises or increases, against 3 of 8 lowered or mixed updates (38%), none with a direction word.
Of the 50 releases, 43 gave annual guidance, and 28 of those 43 (65%) stated it in the headline block or the opening text. The direction of the change decides the placement. Assurant put "Increases Full-Year Outlook" in its headline. Ensign Group used "Raises 2026 Annual Earnings Guidance," and Brinker International wrote "Updates Fiscal 2027 Guidance" in its headline, a raise that the headline wording does not name.
Lowered guidance sits deeper or goes unlabeled. Lennar first stated its lower 2026 delivery target inside the CEO quote. Xylem cut revenue and earnings-per-share guidance, and the cut first appears in the Outlook section. Regal Rexnord lowered GAAP earnings-per-share guidance because of a goodwill impairment and raised adjusted guidance, and both changes appear in a Guidance Update section after the executive quotes. Three lowered or mixed updates did reach the headline block, but as "updates" with no direction: BioMarin wrote "Updates Full-year 2026 Guidance" in a subhead while lowering its revenue and earnings-per-share outlook, Flowserve paired "Updates 2026 Guidance" with "Strong Q3 Performance," and Kroger used "Updates Guidance for 2026" in its headline.
| Direction of change | Releases | Headline block | Opening text | Executive quote | Later section |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Raised | 18 | 13 | 2 | 0 | 3 |
| Lowered or mixed | 8 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 3 |
| Maintained | 7 | 1 | 4 | 1 | 1 |
The gap holds without the six real estate companies in the sample, all of them real estate investment trusts (REITs). Four of the six raised guidance and put it in the subhead. Without those four, 9 of 14 raises (64%) reached the headline block, 7 with a direction word, against 3 of 8 lowered or mixed updates (38%), none with one.
What happens to the opening when revenue falls?
When revenue falls, the opening usually stays quiet about it: none of the 5 releases with falling revenue named the decline in the headline block, and only 1 stated it in the opening bullets.
Group sizes matter here. Revenue rose in 45 releases (90%) and fell in 5 (10%), so the comparison is descriptive, not statistical. Among the 45 risers, 27 (60%) showed revenue in the headline or opening text. Among the 5 decliners, 2 (40%) did. Decliners were also more likely to carry a setback quote (2 of 5, against 2 of 45) and a lowered guidance update (3 of 5, against 2 of 45).
| Company | Revenue change | Headline block leads with | Decline first appears | Drivers first appear |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lennar | -8.7% | Results only | Results of operations section | Results of operations section |
| Xylem | -3.0% | Orders and earnings | Opening highlights | Lead paragraph |
| AutoNation | -0.4% | Results only | Operational summary table | Tables only |
| Kite Realty Group | -7.2% | Guidance raise and leasing | Income statement table | Not explained in text |
| Ingredion | -1.3% | Results only | Business Review section | Business Review section |
Xylem is the closest case to full disclosure. Its subhead credits "despite a more cautious spending environment," its lead names project timing as the revenue driver, and its highlights show revenue down 3% on a reported basis. Even so, the headline leads with orders and earnings. AutoNation described revenue of about $7.0 billion as "relatively flat" in its lead, and the 0.4% decline appears only in a table. Lennar's executive quote cited $8.0 billion of revenue without stating that it had dropped, though it opened with a clear setback: "While our earnings of $1.19 per share were below expectations."
Ingredion shows the split between earnings candor and revenue candor. Its CEO wrote, "Our third quarter results fell short of our expectations," and its highlights carried a guidance cut. The 1% sales decline, tied to the sale of its Pakistan business, first appears in the Business Review. Kite Realty Group opened with a guidance raise and a leasing record while revenue fell 7.2%, a decline visible only in the income statement.
Does the explanation come before the executive quote?
For most releases it does not: 32 of 50 (64%) first explain the quarter in an executive quote or a later section, and only 18 (36%) do so in the headline block or opening bullets.
| Where the first explanation appears | Revenue up (n=45) | Revenue down (n=5) | All 50 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Headline block | 4 | 1 | 5 (10%) |
| Opening text | 13 | 0 | 13 (26%) |
| Executive quote | 22 | 4 | 26 (52%) |
| Later section | 6 | 0 | 6 (12%) |
The executive quote does most of the explaining. In 35 of 50 releases (70%) the first quote names drivers. In 9 (18%) it offers a general statement of satisfaction, 4 (8%) address a setback, 1 repeats a figure and 1 release has no quote.
The split by index is wide. In the S&P 500 group, 13 of 25 releases (52%) explain the quarter in the headline block or opening bullets. In the S&P MidCap 400 group, 5 of 25 (20%) do. Smaller issuers lean on the quote and on later sections, a point worth remembering when a team copies the format of a larger peer.
Do companies put GAAP or adjusted earnings first?
Companies put GAAP earnings first in almost every case: only 4 of 50 releases led with a non-GAAP figure before the comparable GAAP figure.
Of the 41 releases that showed adjusted earnings in the headline or opening text, 40 (98%) also showed GAAP earnings there. The exception was MP Materials, whose GAAP net loss first appears in a financial highlights table after the opening bullets. Four releases put a non-GAAP figure ahead of the GAAP figure: Assurant, Kroger, Ingersoll Rand and MP Materials. Assurant placed GAAP net income in the first row of its opening table, and Kroger and Ingersoll Rand showed GAAP results in the highlights that followed.
This matters most when the two measures point in different directions. Global Payments opened with GAAP diluted EPS of $1.06 against $2.64 a year earlier, and its bullet shows adjusted EPS up 10%. Regal Rexnord listed a $12 million GAAP net loss against an $80 million profit a year earlier, ahead of adjusted EBITDA up 4%. In both releases the weaker GAAP figure comes first.
Did one sector drive these patterns?
No single sector drove the main findings: removing any one of the 11 sectors moved the headline-or-opening revenue share between 55% and 62%, against 58% for all 50.
The share of releases that explain the quarter in the headline block or opening text ranged from 32% to 41% across the same checks, against 36% overall. The share that state guidance in the headline block ranged from 32% to 39%, against 36%. REITs lean toward subhead guidance, which is why this article reports the raised-versus-lowered comparison with and without them. The index split above is a separate difference that the sector checks do not explain.
What should an earnings-release opening look like?
A strong opening puts the guidance direction, the revenue change, the GAAP result and the reason for the quarter in the headline block and opening bullets, in that order of importance.
This recommendation comes from the gaps in the sample, not from a test of what performs best. Each row below targets something most of the 50 releases left for later.
| Element | What to include | Evidence from the sample |
|---|---|---|
| Headline | Company, period and the one fact that defines the quarter. Name any guidance change with a direction word. | Raised guidance reached the headline block in 13 of 18 releases, 11 with a direction word. Lowered or mixed guidance did in 3 of 8, none with one. |
| First bullet | Revenue with the direction and the percent change. | Revenue appears in 8 of 50 headline blocks and 29 of 50 headline or opening texts. |
| Second bullet | GAAP earnings with the prior-year figure, then the adjusted measure beside it, labeled. | 4 of 50 led with non-GAAP. 40 of 41 releases with adjusted figures also showed GAAP. |
| Driver sentence | One sentence before the quote naming the main reasons. When revenue fell, put the reason in the same bullet as the decline. | Only 18 of 50 explain the quarter before the quote. Only 1 of 5 decliners stated the decline in the opening. |
| Guidance bullet | Measure, prior range, new range and direction, whether up, down or unchanged. | Lowered guidance first appeared in a quote or later section in 4 of 8 releases. The 3 that reached the headline said only "updates." |
| Executive quote | A reason, a named setback or a forward step. Do not repeat the bullets. | 9 of 50 quotes were general statements and 1 repeated a figure. |
The sequence also helps outside readers who summarize releases. Search tools and AI assistants often pull the first sentences of a document, so a release whose bullets hold the figure, the comparison and the reason gives them a complete block to quote. A release that holds the reason for a lowered forecast in paragraph six gives them only the number.
- Write the headline with the period and the main fact.
- Add the guidance direction to the headline or subhead.
- Open the bullets with revenue and its change.
- Follow with GAAP earnings and the comparable adjusted figure.
- State the main reason in one sentence before the quote.
- Give the quote a job the bullets do not already do.
Teams that manage investor communications can compare a draft against this sequence alongside the earnings-day steps on 5WPR's investor relations for public companies page.
What are the limits of this study?
The study covers 50 releases for one reporting period, so it describes how these issuers wrote, not how all issuers write.
- Only 5 releases showed falling revenue, so revenue-down comparisons are examples with counts, not statistical tests.
- Index membership came from public list mirrors, not S&P Dow Jones Indices files.
- Seven roster companies were replaced because no fiscal quarter ended in the window, using a rule set before reading releases.
- The study codes where a statement appears. It does not judge whether the statement was complete or fair.
- It does not measure investor response, stock movement or media pickup.
The evidence workbook lists all 50 source links, the coding decisions and the comparison tables.
CONCLUSION
Earnings releases open with numbers and wait to give reasons. The sample shows raised guidance in the headline, lowered guidance deeper in the text, falling revenue in a table, and the explanation of the quarter inside a quote. A team that moves the direction, the change and the reason into the first lines gives every reader the same complete picture, whether they read the full release or only the top. Contact 5WPR to build that opening with your investor relations team. 5W runs AI Search (GEO) programs for brands across consumer, B2B, financial services, healthcare, and technology, building the machine-readable footprint that gets brands cited, not just ranked. Learn more at 5wpr.com/practice/generative-engine-optimization.
Frequently asked questions
How many earnings releases did 5WPR audit?
5WPR audited 50 releases from 50 U.S. public companies, 25 from the S&P 500 and 25 from the S&P MidCap 400, for fiscal quarters ending July 1 to September 30, 2026.
Does the study show which earnings release structure works best?
No. The study benchmarks what issuers put first. It does not measure investor response or test which structure performs better.
Should a company put guidance in the headline?
Of 43 releases with annual guidance, 18 first stated it in the headline block and 28 in the headline or opening text. Raised guidance reached the headline block far more often than lowered guidance, which is why the recommended opening asks for a direction word in either case.
Do companies lead with adjusted earnings before GAAP earnings?
Rarely. Four of 50 releases led with a non-GAAP figure before the comparable GAAP figure, and 40 of the 41 releases that showed adjusted earnings up front also showed GAAP earnings up front.
Can a company use this study to review its own release?
Yes. The recommended opening is built from the gaps in the sample, and a communications team can check its own draft against each row of the table.
About the author
Ronn Torossian is Founder and Chairman of 5W, a PR, creative and AI Visibility agency headquartered in Miami with offices in Tampa and New York. He founded 5W in 2003, is the author of For Immediate Release, and is a guest lecturer at Harvard, NYU and other universities. Reviewed by the 5W editorial team.




