Skip to content
5WPR
Get in touch
Ragan PR Daily Awards5W is a 2026 PR Agency of the Year FinalistRagan's PR Daily Awards · Read the announcement →

Public Relations · Published May 15, 2025

Erica Kirwin
Chief People Officer

Authentic DEI PR Campaigns: 7 Rules and 4 Case Lessons

diverse team collaborating on a project for team building
Share:

Authentic DEI public relations campaigns follow seven rules, from acting before announcing to responding fast when criticism comes. McKinsey's 2020 Diversity Wins report found that top-quartile companies for ethnic and cultural diversity on executive teams beat the bottom quartile by 36 percent in profitability in 2019, a correlation and not proof of cause.

Last updated: November 12, 2026. Originally published May 2025.

Summary: how to build an authentic DEI campaign

  • Begin with real actions inside the organization, then communicate them.
  • Let the audience's own words shape the message.
  • Use stories from community members, and do not speak for them.
  • Back every claim with a fact the audience can check.
  • Measure both numbers and the quality of representation.
  • Commit for the long term, not for one campaign.

Rule 1: Why should DEI actions come before the announcement?

Authentic DEI in PR means creating campaigns that reflect the full range of human experience while working to remove barriers that have historically excluded certain groups. DEI goes beyond representation: it requires systematic changes in how an organization communicates with and about different communities. Audiences are skeptical of DEI messaging that prioritizes optics over substance, so a record of action matters more than the wording of any single statement.

Start with an internal assessment of current messaging, the composition of the team and the decision-making process. A team that does not reflect the audiences it speaks to is more likely to misjudge tone, context or cultural nuance. Align PR messaging with concrete commitments, so that nothing in a statement runs ahead of what the organization has done.

The 8-step order of work for an authentic DEI campaign
  1. Audit current practice: review hiring, leadership, supplier, product and past messaging for gaps.
  2. Choose one or two commitments the organization can keep and measure.
  3. Listen to the audience through surveys, interviews and community leaders before drafting any message.
  4. Build the story from real people and real actions, with their consent and credit.
  5. Pick channels and outlets the audience already trusts, including community and trade media.
  6. Review every asset with people who understand the community, and check language against the AP Stylebook.
  7. Publish with proof points, such as dates, numbers and named programs, not slogans.
  8. Report progress on a schedule, including what has not yet worked.

Rule 2: How do you let the audience's own voice shape the message?

You let the audience shape the message by listening before you write. A simple four-part framework helps PR teams craft a specific pro-diversity message:

PartWhat to do
AuthenticityLook for ways your company is genuinely diverse, starting with your own team and its diversity of thought and culture, rather than manufacturing a surface-level veneer of diversity.
Reflect their voiceIf your brand currently lacks diversity of culture or perspective internally, listen closely to what your current and prospective audience is saying, thinking and wanting, and let that shape the message.
Find your storyDiversity messaging is anchored in story. Test whether your brand's story actually resonates with the audience you are trying to reach, and adjust the language and emphasis if it does not.
Make connectionsIdentify the media channels and voices your target audience already trusts, and treat them as partners rather than distribution channels.

Rule 3: How do you tell community stories without speaking for people?

You create inclusive content by paying attention to language, imagery and storytelling. The Associated Press Stylebook provides updated guidelines for inclusive language that respect diverse identities and experiences. Visual representation matters, but authentic representation goes beyond including diverse faces: it requires thoughtful consideration of context, roles and storytelling. These approaches help:

  • Use person-first language that emphasizes humanity over characteristics.
  • Feature authentic stories from community members rather than speaking for them.
  • Include diverse perspectives in all stages of campaign development.
  • Ensure accessibility in all communications materials.

Rule 4: How do you back each DEI claim with proof?

You back each DEI claim by pairing it with a fact the audience can check. A claim with no proof reads as a slogan, and journalists and audiences are quick to test it.

Claim typeWeak versionProof to publish
Workforce"We value diversity"Representation data by level, with the year and method
Leadership"Our leaders reflect our customers"Leadership makeup and the plan to change it
Community"We support our communities"Named partners, funding amounts and outcomes
Suppliers"We work with diverse partners"Share of spend with diverse suppliers, and the target
Accessibility"Our content is for everyone"Captions, alt text and accessibility standards used

Rule 5: How do you measure DEI impact in PR campaigns?

You measure DEI impact with both quantitative and qualitative metrics, so that progress is tracked and the value of the work can be shown.

TypeWhat to track
QuantitativeRepresentation in campaign materials; audience engagement across demographic groups; media coverage in diverse outlets; brand sentiment among various communities
QualitativeAuthenticity of representation; community feedback and responses; long-term relationship building; internal team perspectives

For a wider measurement approach, see 5W's guide to measuring PR effectiveness.

Rule 6: How do you build community relationships and train your team?

Successful DEI initiatives rely on strong relationships with the communities they speak to, and on a team trained to work with them. Relationships require:

  • Long-term commitment to community engagement
  • Regular consultation with community leaders
  • Support for community initiatives beyond PR campaigns
  • Transparent communication about organizational goals and progress

PR professionals also need ongoing training to develop cultural competence and DEI expertise. Effective programs cover:

  • Cultural competency and sensitivity
  • Unconscious bias awareness
  • Inclusive language and communication
  • Community engagement strategies

Rule 7: What should you do if a DEI campaign is criticized?

If a DEI campaign is criticized, respond quickly, listen first and act on what is valid. A defensive or silent response usually makes the story larger. Follow this order:

  1. Read the criticism in full and identify what is accurate before replying.
  2. Acknowledge the specific concern in plain language, and avoid generic statements.
  3. Name the action the organization will take, with a date.
  4. Speak directly with the affected community and the journalists covering the story.
  5. Update the campaign or withdraw the asset if it caused harm.
  6. Report back publicly on what changed.

This sits within a wider response plan, covered by 5W's crisis communications practice, and by the journalist side in the media relations guide.

What can four past DEI campaigns teach PR teams?

Past campaigns that clearly succeeded or failed make these rules concrete. Three well-known missteps show what happens when diversity messaging is a surface-level marketing device instead of a reflection of real organizational values, and one campaign shows the opposite.

Pepsi and Kendall Jenner (April 2017)

Pepsi pulled an ad featuring Kendall Jenner that tried to place the brand within a cultural moment around social movements, after widespread criticism that it was tone-deaf.

Dolce & Gabbana (November 2018)

Dolce & Gabbana faced backlash after a video ad series showed a Chinese model struggling to eat pizza and other Western foods with chopsticks. The ads were seen as portraying Chinese consumers as unsophisticated, and the fallout included products pulled from retailers and a cancelled Shanghai fashion show after models and celebrities withdrew.

PepsiCo and "Lady Doritos" (February 2018)

Then-PepsiCo CEO Indra Nooyi said on the Freakonomics podcast that women snack differently from men. Media coverage dubbed the idea "Lady Doritos," and PepsiCo said it had no plans for such a product. The episode shows how a remark about gender can be turned into a story the company did not intend.

Wells Fargo "Learning Sign Language"

Wells Fargo's "Learning Sign Language" campaign highlighted the importance of including people with disabilities in everyday public communication, building the message around genuine accessibility rather than a single marketing moment. The common thread across successful DEI campaigns is that the message grows out of an existing organizational commitment, instead of being layered on after the fact.

What are the common DEI pitfalls?

The most common DEI pitfalls are tokenism and short-term thinking. Tokenism treats diversity as a marketing device instead of a commitment, and audiences often notice. Short-term thinking undermines DEI efforts too, because effective DEI requires sustained commitment rather than one-off campaigns or reactive responses to social issues. A short pre-publish check catches most problems:

  • Is every claim backed by a fact the organization can show?
  • Did people from the community help shape and review the message?
  • Does the campaign match what the company does in hiring, products and partnerships?
  • Is there a plan to report progress after the campaign ends?
  • Has the team reviewed images, captions and language for stereotypes?

Frequently asked questions

What makes a DEI PR campaign authentic?

An authentic DEI PR campaign grows out of real organizational commitments, listens to the audience's own voice and tells stories from community members, instead of layering a message over a campaign after the fact.

How do you measure a DEI PR campaign?

Measure both numbers, such as representation in materials, engagement across groups and coverage in diverse outlets, and qualities such as the authenticity of representation, community feedback and long-term relationships.

What did McKinsey's Diversity Wins report find?

McKinsey's 2020 report found that companies in the top quartile for ethnic and cultural diversity on executive teams outperformed those in the fourth quartile by 36 percent in profitability in 2019. It describes a correlation, not proof that diversity causes the difference.

What is the biggest mistake in DEI communications?

The biggest mistake is tokenism, treating diversity as a marketing device. Short-term, one-off campaigns that are not backed by sustained commitment also weaken DEI efforts.

How should a company respond to criticism of a DEI campaign?

Respond quickly, acknowledge the specific concern, name an action with a date, speak with the affected community and report back on what changed.

Should a DEI campaign be announced before the work is done?

No. Communicate commitments the organization can already show, and share progress as it happens, so that nothing in a statement runs ahead of the facts.

Conclusion

Creating authentic DEI-focused PR campaigns requires commitment, understanding and continuous learning. Start by assessing current PR practices through a DEI lens, set clear goals and metrics, build relationships with diverse communities, invest in team training and create systems for measuring and adjusting the approach.

Erica Kirwin

Written by

Erica Kirwin

Erica is a seasoned HR practitioner and strategic partner who has spent 15 years leading people teams across the retail, healthcare, and creative communications sectors. She is passionate about the employee experience, ensuring talent and business strategies align, and building policies that are progressive and inclusive for all employees.

View all articles by Erica Kirwin →

Get in touch

Let's build your next chapter.

Tell us what you're working on. A senior strategist will respond within one business day.

Email
info@5wpr.com
Phone
212.999.5585
Offices
Miami · HQ100 SE 2nd Street, Floor 38
Miami, FL 33131
Tampa110 South 12th Street
Tampa, FL 33602
New York469 7th Avenue, Floor 8
New York, NY 10018