The 3 best crypto exchange transparency campaigns here each gave users a way to check solvency instead of taking it on faith. Kraken publishes proof of reserves that includes client liabilities and reported a 114.9% Bitcoin reserve ratio in March 2025, Binance launched its program within days of the FTX collapse and added zero-knowledge proofs, and Bitvavo lets customers verify their balances against a quarterly independent attestation.
Last updated: November 16, 2026. Figures are as published by each exchange or its reporting outlet and are not independently audited by 5W.
Summary: three transparency programs
- Kraken says it pioneered proof of reserves in 2014 and has committed to regular attestations since January 2022, with client liabilities in every report.
- Binance announced its program days after FTX filed for bankruptcy in November 2022 and later added zk-SNARK verification, a system that Hacken researchers found a flaw in four days after release.
- Bitvavo publishes a quarterly attestation by The Network Firm and a tool for customers to verify their own balances.
- Proof of reserves shows assets at a point in time. It does not by itself prove solvency, which is the main criticism of the category.
- The communication around a proof decides whether users believe it, so a program needs a schedule, a named auditor and a tool a non-technical user can run.
Which exchange transparency campaigns made this list?
This list covers three exchange transparency programs, each chosen because the exchange publishes its method and results on its own pages. They are 5W's picks of clear mechanisms, not a ranking of which exchange is safest, and each has limits described below.
| Program | Exchange | Mechanism | What it published |
|---|---|---|---|
| Proof of Reserves | Kraken | Merkle tree with an independent accountancy firm | Total client liabilities, personalized Merkle proofs, reserve ratios by asset |
| Proof of Reserves with zk-SNARKs | Binance | Merkle tree plus a zero-knowledge proof | User-level verification, open-source verification code |
| Quarterly Proof of Reserves | Bitvavo | Merkle tree with an independent accounting firm | Reserve ratios by asset, customer verification tool |
What are the best crypto exchange transparency campaigns?
The three programs below show a long-running program, a fast response to a crisis and a quarterly program from a regional exchange.
1. Kraken: liabilities as well as assets
Kraken says it pioneered proof of reserves in 2014 and conducts it regularly, according to its September 2025 report, which was attested as of September 30, 2025 and covers BTC, ETH, SOL, USDC, USDT, XRP and ADA. The report includes margin accounts, futures holdings and staked assets, and gives each client a personalized Merkle proof to confirm inclusion without exposing anyone else's data.
In its March 2025 report, Kraken said it held 192,091.25 BTC against customer balances of 167,188.68 BTC, a reserve ratio of 114.9%. Its 2024 attestation covered more than $21.5 billion of client assets, with The Network Firm, a registered CPA firm, attesting to Kraken's control of the wallets.
Why it works: Kraken includes total client liabilities in every report and says plainly that a proof that shows only assets is a partial one, which gives it a clear standard other exchanges are measured against.
2. Binance: a program launched within days of FTX
Binance announced its proof-of-reserves plan in the days after FTX filed for bankruptcy in November 2022, and CEO Changpeng Zhao urged exchanges to publish wallet evidence, as CryptoSlate has described. Binance's proof-of-reserves page lets users find their Merkle leaf and record ID to confirm that their balance was included, and states that a zk-SNARK proves the leaf balances add up to the claimed total.
The program also shows the risk of moving fast. Hacken reports that its researchers found a missing range check in the zk-SNARK implementation four days after Binance released it in February 2023. Critics note that a Merkle proof shows inclusion but not that every liability was counted.
Why it works: A fast, public response to a crisis of confidence gave users something to check within days. The flaw and the criticism show that the credibility of a proof depends on scrutiny of how it was built.
3. Bitvavo: a quarterly attestation customers can check
Bitvavo, a European exchange, publishes a proof-of-reserves page stating that The Network Firm LLP, an independent accounting firm, confirms that select customer assets are backed 1:1. The page says attestations are quarterly, shows reserve ratios by asset as of September 30, 2025, and lets customers generate a report to verify their own balances.
Why it works: A fixed quarterly schedule, a named auditor and a verification tool a customer can use in a few clicks made the program easy to explain and easy to check.
What makes a crypto exchange audit trustworthy?
A trustworthy exchange audit covers reserve attestations, security testing and anti-money-laundering procedures together, because users care whether their money exists, whether security controls work and whether the platform follows the rules. An audit report that sits on a website as an unread PDF does little for confidence, so the findings need to be explained in plain language.
Disclosing issues alongside a clear remediation timeline builds more credibility than claiming a perfect result, since users have learned to distrust claims of perfection. Real-time reporting adds to this: live dashboards showing reserve ratios, audit dates and security status let users check platform health between scheduled reports, and 5W's view is that aggregated reserve data gives depositors confidence without exposing individual positions.
How should an exchange communicate a security incident?
An exchange should communicate a security incident with approved messaging templates for each severity level, one designated spokesperson and a prioritized notification list that puts investors, key customers and regulators ahead of the press. All three have to exist before an incident, because the clock starts in minutes.
| Severity | What the message must include |
|---|---|
| Minor: limited systems, no evidence of exploitation | Acknowledge the issue, state the immediate remediation steps and give a timeline for the full fix |
| Medium: unauthorized access to non-critical systems | Everything in the minor message, plus a customer impact assessment and third-party validation of the response |
| Major breach | What happened, what data or funds were affected, what the exchange is doing about it and how it will prevent a recurrence |
Timing separates effective responses from damaging ones. Investors and key customers should hear about an incident before they read about it in the press, updates should arrive at regular intervals even when there is nothing new, and an initial message should never understate the severity only to revise it upward later.
How should an exchange present its security certifications?
An exchange should present security certifications as outcomes for the user, not as badges, because a certificate name means little to most depositors. A SOC 2 Type II report covers how a company's security controls operated over a period of time, and ISO 27001 certifies an information security management system, so the useful message explains which controls the certification required and what they protect.
A new certification is also a news story. The announcement should say what the audit required, which controls the exchange implemented and what that means for customer assets, and it should be pitched to crypto and financial reporters with that angle. The cybersecurity PR practice covers how that positioning is built.
How can an exchange copy these campaigns?
An exchange can copy these campaigns by making its proof specific, scheduled and checkable. Six steps keep the work in order.
- Publish reserves alongside total client liabilities, as Kraken does, and state the audit scope.
- Name the independent firm and the snapshot date for every report, as Bitvavo does.
- Give users a tool to verify their own balance in a few clicks, and explain it in plain language.
- Put the build under outside scrutiny, publish the verification code and fix flaws in public, the lesson of the Binance zk-SNARK review.
- Announce a schedule and keep to it, so the program does not look like a reaction to the news cycle.
- Prepare incident templates, a spokesperson and a notification order before an incident happens.
A press release announcing a concrete reserve figure, an audit cadence and a verification tool gives journalists something to evaluate, while a vague commitment to transparency gives them nothing to hold the exchange to. The wider program, including crisis response and AI search visibility, is laid out on the crypto PR company page, the Crypto Trust Index adds research on how trust in crypto brands is measured, and the financial services and fintech PR practice builds these programs for exchanges and other crypto brands.
Frequently asked questions
What is proof of reserves for a crypto exchange?
Proof of reserves is a process in which an exchange shows it holds at least as many assets as it owes clients, usually with a Merkle tree that lets each user confirm their balance was included. It shows a point in time and does not by itself prove solvency.
How often should a crypto exchange publish proof of reserves?
There is no single standard. Kraken and Bitvavo describe regular or quarterly attestations, and some exchanges publish monthly. Whatever the cadence, it should be announced and kept.
Why does including client liabilities matter?
Kraken says a proof that shows only assets is a partial one, because it omits what the exchange owes. Including total client liabilities lets users see the reserve ratio, not just a balance.
What went wrong with Binance's zk-SNARK system?
Hacken reports that its researchers found a missing range check in the implementation four days after Binance released it in February 2023, which shows why outside review of the build matters.
What should an exchange audit actually cover?
Reserve attestations, security penetration testing and anti-money-laundering procedure review together, since users judge safety by solvency, security and compliance as one picture.
What should an exchange prepare before a security incident?
Approved messaging for each severity level, one designated spokesperson and a notification list that reaches investors, key customers and regulators before the press.






